Welcome to the Gray Cottage - a rare opportunity awaiting on the coveted Lake Simcoe shoreline. Offered for sale for the first time in over 60 years, this 3-season cottage is nestled on 70ft of prime Lake Simcoe shorefront, offering a peaceful retreat surrounded by towering trees and lush natural landscapes. The Gray Cottage maintains its nostalgic charm with a cozy interior that features 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 powder rooms & a separate shower room. Entertain guests with ease in the open-concept living/dining that features a large stone fireplace w/woodstove insert, large breakfast bar, & oversized windows with westerly exposure for breathtaking views of infamous Lake Simcoe sunsets. Walk to the waters edge where the rhythmic sound of waves lapping the natural shoreline is a constant companion, adding to the cottage's tranquil atmosphere. Renovate & restore the existing charm of the existing cottage or build your dream 4-season home in the exclusive McRae Beach community and enjoy the alluring tradition of Lake Simcoe's cottage culture for years to come.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
Bungalow
Total Approx Floor Area:
1100-1500
Lot Depth:
221'½"67.4 m
Lot Frontage:
70'⅛"21.3 m
Direction Faces:
West
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
2.0
Water supply:
Well
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
4
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
7
Heating type:
Other
Heating Fuel:
Wood
Foundation:
Block
Roof:
Asphalt Shingle
Basement:
Crawl Space
Fireplace Features:
Wood Stove, Living Room
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Alternative Power:
Unknown
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Other Structures:
Garden Shed
Parking Features:
Front Yard Parking, Private
Parking Spaces:
6
Total Parking Spaces:
6.0
Rural services:
Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Garbage Pickup, Internet High Speed, Natural Gas On Road, Recycling Pickup, Telephone Available, Street Lights, Cell Services
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
IMMED
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Assessment Year:
2025
Taxes:
$6,426 /
2024
Assessment:
$- /
2025
York
Georgina
Pefferlaw
Beach, Clear View, Golf, Lake/Pond, School, Waterfront
Primary Bedroom - Main Floor, Water Heater Owned
Deck, Fishing
Unknown
fridge, stove, AELF, HWT, all existing window coverings, garden sheds, furnishings are negotiable
Data was last updated October 15, 2025 at 08:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
26
Avg list price:
$832,000
Min list price:
$540,000
Max list price:
$3,499,900
Avg days on market:
33
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
195
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type
and located in
Pefferlaw. Average values are
derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website.
The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.